Conspiracy Theories Triumphant in Turkey
by Daniel Pipes
Feb 5, 2013
Cross-posted from National Review Online, The Corner
I wrote in The Hidden Hand, my 1996 book surveying conspiracy theories in the Middle East, that
Turkey and Israel stand out as the only two Middle Eastern countries where leaders are fully accountable to electorates, where the West is viewed more as an ally than as an enemy, and where conspiracy theories have a relatively minor role in public life. ... Few mainstream politician, intellectual, or religious leaders [in Turkey] engage in conspiratorial thinking, which exists mostly at the fringes of polite society.
How sadly have things changed in the intervening years. Here's one example of many, not more egregious but more spectacular than most:
On Jan. 30, Israeli warplanes struck targets in Syria. A week later, the exact details remain murky, but it concerned the transfer of advanced armaments by the Syrian regime to the Hizbullah terrorist group in Lebanon.
One might expect the Turkish authorities to applaud this step, both because it did damage to the regime Ankara wants to overthrow and because those advanced armaments could potentially be used against Turkish interests.
But no, both the government and the communist opposition spun elaborate and unconvincing conspiracy theories about the Israel raid.
Government: Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu criticized the Syrian government for not responding to the Israeli attack and spoke of a secret deal.
"Why has the Syrian army, which has been attacking its own people with warplanes and tanks for 22 months, not responded to this Israeli operation? Why doesn't [Bashar al-Assad] throw a stone at the Israeli planes while they fly over his palace and insult his nation's honor?
Why doesn't he do anything against Israel while he drops bombs on the innocent people of his country? Is there a secret agreement between Israel and Assad?" He suggested that the Israeli air strikes serve the interests of the Syrian government, arguing that Assad is "exploiting" the Israeli attack to increase his support among Muslims.
Opposition: SANA, the Syrian news agency, quotes Bulent Esinoglu, vice chairman of Turkish Labor Party (EMEP), saying that the AKP government in Turkey "has cooperated with Israel in its aggression" on Syria.
He goes on to claim that Davutoglu turned a blind eye to this event and that "the Turkish Government was aware of the aggression in advance."
In brief, the government has Assad cooperating with Israel and the communists have Prime Minister Erdogan cooperating with Israel.
Comments: (1) This sort of reasoning can quickly leave one with a sore head. (2) With inane conspiracy theories flying back and forth, the population gets confused, public life is degraded, and the portents for Turkey look dim. (February 4, 2013)
This text may be reposted or forwarded so long as it is presented as an integral whole with complete AND ACCURATE information provided about its author, date, place of publication, and original URL.
- Why Arabs can't Handle Liberty
- Conspiracy Theories Triumphant in Turkey
- 140,000 Canisters of U.S. Teargas to Egypt's Morsi
- Is telling the truth Islam bashing?
- What do Arabs say of the Palestinian refugees?
- Examining Hamas and Hezbollah
- Can we please cut the quackery?
- In Academia, Hiring Token Jews
- Moderate Muslims Must Seize the Reins of Islam
- Why Arabs can't Handle Liberty
- "A moderate Islamist is as fantastical as a moderate Nazi"
- Looking at Tunisia (going Islamist)
- France Waking Up to Its Anti-Semitism?
- Reflections on Current Hamas-Israel Hostilities
- Israel's Arab Spring
- Christians in Syria: Separating Fact from Fiction
- Ayman Zawahiri and Egypt: A Trip Through Time
What does Al Gore say about the 'science' behind climate change?
"As it happens, the idea of social justice is inextricably linked in the Scriptures with ecology."
- Exploring Religion and Environmentalism
- Taking a Sober View on Climate Change
- Social Agenda Behind Environmentalism
- Environmental-Government Complex is about Money
- From Leslie J. Sacks:
- Political Correctness - Our Titanic
- Why Islam is in Desperate Need of a Reformation
- Death of Democracy by President Obama?
- Unspoken Racism of America by Leslie Sacks