St Augustine: Manichean and Neoplatonist Period
In this frame of mind he was ready to be affected by the Manichean propaganda
which was then actively carried on in Africa, without apparently being much
hindered by the imperial edict against assemblies of the sect. Two things
especially attracted him to the Manicheans: they felt at liberty to criticize
the Scriptures, particularly the Old Testament, with perfect freedom; and they
held chastity and self-denial in honor.
The former fitted in with the impression which the Bible had made on Augustine himself; the latter corresponded closely to his mood at the time. The prayer which he tells us he had in his heart then, " Lord, give me chastity and temperance, but not now," may be taken as the formula which represents the attitude of many of the Manichean auditores.
Among these Augustine was classed during his nineteenth year; but he went no further, though he held firmly to Manicheanism for nine years, during which he endeavored to convert all his friends, scorned the sacraments of the Church, and held frequent disputations with catholic believers.
Having finished his studies, he returned to Thagaste and began to teach
grammar, living in the house of Romanianus, a prominent citizen who had been of
much service to him since his father's death, and whom he converted to
Monnica deeply grieved at her son's heresy, forbade him her house, until reassured by a vision that promised his restoration. She comforted herself also by the word of a certain bishop (probably of Thagaste) that "the child of so many tears could not be lost."
He seems to have spent little more than a year in Thagaste, when the desire for a wider field, together with the death of a dear friend, moved him to return to Carthage as a teacher of rhetoric.
The next period was a time of diligent study, and produced (about the end of
380) the treatise, long since lost, De pulchro et apto.
Meanwhile the hold of Manicheanism on him was loosening. Its feeble cosmology and metaphysics had long since failed to satisfy him, and the astrological superstitions springing from the credulity of its disciples offended his reason.
The members of the sect, unwilling to lose him, had great hopes from a meeting with their leader Faustus of Mileve; but when he came to Carthage in the autumn of 382, he too proved disappointing, and Augustine ceased to be at heart a Manichean.
He was not yet, however, prepared to put anything in the place of the doctrine he
had held, and remained in outward communion with his former associates while he
pursued his search for truth. Soon after his Manichean convictions had broken
down, he left Carthage for Rome, partly, it would seem, to escape the
preponderating influence of his mother on a mind which craved perfect freedom of
Here he was brought more than ever, by obligations of friendship and gratitude, into close association with Manicheans, of whom there were many in Rome, not merely auditores but perfecti or fully initiated members. This did not last long, however, for the prefect Symmachus sent him to Milan, certainly before the beginning of 385, in answer to a request for a professor of rhetoric.
The change of residence completed Augustine's separation from Manicheanism.
He listened to the preaching of Ambrose and by it was made acquainted with the
allegorical interpretation of the Scriptures and the weakness of the Manichean
Biblical criticism, but he was not yet ready to accept catholic Christianity.
His mind was still under the influence of the skeptical philosophy of the later
This was the least satisfactory stage in his mental development, though his external circumstances were increasingly favorable. He had his mother again with him now, and shared a house and garden with her and his devoted friends Alypius and Nebridius, who had followed him to Milan; his assured social position is shown also by the fact that, in deference to his mother's entreaties, he was formally betrothed to a woman of suitable station. As a catechumen of the Church, he listened regularly to the sermons of Ambrose.
The bishop, though as yet he knew nothing of Augustine's internal struggles, had welcomed him in the friendliest manner both for his own and for Monnica's sake. Yet Augustine was attracted only by Ambrose's eloquence, not by his faith; now he agreed, and now he questioned.
Morally his life was perhaps at its lowest
point. On his betrothal, he had put away the mother of his son; but neither the
grief which he felt at this parting nor regard for his future wife, who was as
yet too young for marriage, prevented him from taking a new concubine for the
two intervening years. Sensuality, however, began to pall upon him, little a s
he cared to struggle against it.
His idealism was by no means dead; he told Romanian, who came to Milan at this time on business, that he wished lie could live altogether in accordance with the dictates of philosophy; and a plan was even made for the foundation of a community retired from the world, which should live entirely for the pursuit of truth.
With this project his intention of marriage and his ambition interfered, and Augustine was further off than ever from peace of mind.
In his thirty-first year he was strongly attracted to Neoplatonism by the
logic of his development. The idealistic character of this philosophy awoke
unbounded enthusiasm, and he was attracted to it also by its exposition of pure
intellectual being and of the origin of evil.
These doctrines brought him closer to the Church, though he did not yet grasp the full significance of its central doctrine of the personality of Jesus Christ.
In his earlier writings he names this acquaintance with the Neoplatonic teaching and its relation to Christianity as the turning-point of his life, though in the Confessiones it appears only as a statue on the long, road of error.
The truth, as it may be established by a
careful comparison of his earlier and later writings, is that his idealism had
been distinctly strengthened by Neoplatonism, which had at the same time
revealed his own, will, and not a natura altera in him, as the subject of
his baser desires.
This made the conflict between ideal and actual in his life more unbearable than ever. Yet his sensual desires were still so strong that it seemed impossible for him to break away from them.
Extract from St Augustine IEP 2001 Ref url: http://www.utm.edu/research/iep/a/augustin.htm
- St. Augustine and Evolution
- Saint Augustine and the Western Christian World-View
- Early Years of St Augustine
- St Augustine: Development of His Views
- St Augustine: Conversion and Ordination
- St. Augustine: Anti-Manicheanism and Pelagian Writings
- St Augustine: Manichean and Neoplatonist Period
- St. Augustine: Activity Against Donatism
- Notes on Neoplatonism
- Early Christian and Medieval Neoplatonism
- Pelagius: To Demetrias, why he was cleared of heresy
- Pelagius: Chapters
- Pelagius and why he was right.
- Defense Of The Freedom Of The Will
- How Christianity drew on Philo's synthesis of Judaism and Hellenism